You guys, time is weird.
I miss a lot of major news stories. They happen overnight, and I’m sleeping. Or trying to.
This morning in the midst of getting Isla ready for school, I’m scrolling through Facebook.
I see the same story a few times, with different commentaries. I told you time is weird.
A teacher has gone viral for carrying a wheelchair-using student on his back during a field trip.

Oh, boy.
We’ve got the inspiration porn out there with stuff like: OMG, this is the best thing you’ll see all day!
And then we’ve got my fellow disabled writers pointing out the ableist issues with inaccessible field trips.
I love a good bit of ableism to wake me up in the morning.
Now that I’m here, let me tell you a story. You know there’s a story, right?
Back in the 80s, like every other awkward girl trying to fit in, I was a Brownie.
For about five minutes.
Stick with me.
My favorite part was selling candy bars. Both my Grandmas would buy their quota, so I could eat them.
So I liked the candy bars and even the badges, and all that being a good person um, stuff.
I did not like the field trips. They meant I got left out a lot. Because of access issues, or inaccessibility to me as a wheelchair user.
If there was a badge that went along with the trip, and I couldn’t actually participate, they’d throw me a badge, anyway. Gee, thanks. But I wanted to do stuff.
One trip was to a carnival. It was one group trip where I actually got to y’know, go with the group.
Now. I love carnivals and fairs. They make me so excited I could throw up, as I famously did at the top of a Ferris wheel one year.
But that was after this Brownies field trip. Possibly to make up for what happened on the Brownies field trip.
What happened was this.
I arrived at the carnival with my Dad. As a kid with divorced parents, my Dad weekends were sacred to me, so two of my favorites in one day meant I was pretty freaking excited.
And so we get there. Hit the carousel first. I went up the steps to the platform. But couldn’t well, get on the horse.
My father, as he did back then, lifted me from one place and put me somewhere else. That’s just what Dads do. And this one is mine. He was doing a very Dad thing.
He was also, that day, making the world fit his disabled daughter. Which is a very my Dad thing to do.
Instead of making disabled people fit the world, which everyone else still makes us do.
So, he’s lifting me. For reasons.
And a Brownie leader comes over to us. Suggests it’s inappropriate for the other girls to see me um, manhandled like that.
But would I like some cotton candy?
Never mind that this is my father, helping me get somewhere otherwise inaccessible to me.
I went around on the carousel one time. And then we were asked to leave, because having to be helped down meant I was um, manhandled twice.
Too many reasonable adjustments for them, I guess.
And then it was suggested that I not move up to Girl Scouts. By Girl Scouts.
Instead of making trips accessible, they chucked out the disabled kid.
Instead of making trips accessible, let’s put disabled people in backpacks. And get praised for it.
Let’s tie disabled kids to their parents legs, call it therapy, and then say they’re walking.

Let’s praise this teacher, instead of finding and highlighting wheelchair accessible nature trails.
I noticed that this kid is happy the story went viral. That’s cool. But disabled people are more than just props for someone’s ‘good deed’.
We need access, not backpacks.
*
If you like my writing, if you’ve ever binged on my blog, or you want video content, consider joining me on Patreon. Become a Patron!
Join the Gin & Lemonade newsletter!
Subscribe to get a roundup of posts and other groovy stuff every week!



27 Comments
My first thought when I hear about a “hero teacher” carrying a kid on their back is “WHY WAS THIS TRIP NOT PLANNED WITH SOME ACCESSIBILITY?” You are a good teacher, Lorna. We are listening.
Thanks, Heather. I’ve just added my voice to the many out there.
I agree with you Lorna, accessibility for disabled people is a big issue..I know this, my husband is paraplegic in a wheelchair, he can’t access all the places he wants
Way to go girl scouts. Not. Seems to be somewhat against the mission statement suggesting a young person shouldn’t try be one 😞
Ohhhh can I get a freaking AMEN! There are so many things in this post that want to rage, cry and hug you for! As a mama of a disabled daughter I SEE YOU!
Thank you, Kari. As I’m a mother myself now, too, life is more interesting and equality is somehow even more important. Love to you and your daughter.
Lorna, yes and no. It IS good to have ppl to help those who need help. And it is equally good and needed indeed that more events become accessible to everybody. As I don’t use FB this escaped my attention. Also I live in Europe and wouldn’t have seen this post anyway. But thanks to your posting I now know. Thank You.
It’s the framing of the action that’s wrong, not the action itself. He’s not a hero because he decided to do it. They should have gone somewhere accessible, he shouldn’t have had to do it, even if he did volunteer.
But if you limited field trips to ONLY easily accessible places you would be keeping these students from seeing things that they wouldn’t otherwise see. I think this class was headed off into the woods on a foot trail that wouldn’t have been suitable for any kind of wheeled vehicle. I do agree 100% with you that there needs to be more accessible things for disabled or challenged people to do, but I think we’ve come a LONG way in just the 60+ years that I’ve been alive. We didn’t have sloped curbs at sidewalk/road intersections, we didn’t have Braille imprinted on sidewalks to let blind people know what corner they’re at, we didn’t have any type of body carriers, we didn’t have electric wheelchairs or the road-worthy wheelchairs that are available now. Just a few days ago I saw a short video that showed a severely autistic girl being wheeled into a lake on a floating lounge chair which Prince Edward Island beaches have just recently provided. This girl is not mobile, she can’t speak at all, and earlier beach visits she could only lie on a towel on the shore and watch the others swim. She was SO delighted when her mother wheeled her into the water on the lounge chair – for the first time in her 12 years of life she felt the waves lapping at her toes. Where I live, a previous politician allocated a large sum of money to create an area in a national park that is all-inclusive, with wooden trails into the trees and down to the fishing pond to make it possible for wheelchair bound fishermen to enjoy. . The campground is accessible with washrooms with large showers and toilet stalls. The campground’s indoor kitchen has lowered countertops and cabinets, lowered sinks for washing dishes. It’s a beautiful set-up and is very well used 12 months of the year – the campground and buildings have been winterized as well. So the technology is coming along – there are just many areas that aren’t suitable for wheelchairs or wagons or anything like that. I would rather see that young girl able to join her classmates on a hiking trip into the woods than left at home. And it has more to do with socialization than with the chance of seeing deer or bears in the woods. Now she will return to school and be able to join in the conversations that her classmates are having about the trip. I am not disabled so I know that I’m not seeing things exactly the way that you do, but I was impressed with what this teacher did for her.
I’m not disparaging field trips or the reason behind them, or the adaptations that already exist. My issue is that the inclusion of disabled people should not be portrayed as an act of heroism. It detracts from the real work/change of perspective that needs to happen, and that disabled people ourselves have been sharing/doing/saying for years. A kid getting to go on a field trip and be equal to her peers should not be news.
I haven’t seen the article, and I’m able bodied. That said, I am conflicted.
I advocate accessibility. I have spent a lot of my working life trying to improve access, particularly for environmental education, but not restricted to this. I don’t like people being excluded, it’s wrong.
That said, teachers are screwed at the moment. They have bugger all in terms of resources, the more time goes on the fewer resources are available and support services are having funding withdrawn.
So when I see this story, I see someone who is doing his best. Not someone who is looking for praise, just someone who is probably out of options himself, but who desperately wants all of his class to share the experience of outdoor education.
The field trip should be accessible, the centre should be accessible. No argument. Why wasn’t this investment put in place?
My argument is with the lack government funding, not with a teacher. For me the story should have taken a different angle, not ‘isn’t he wonderful?’ But ‘this is what teachers now have to do’
Her mother was all set do it. He said he would. He’s a teacher, not the class teacher. No one should be put in that position. Was reading another article last week where another kid was singled out when her mother had to help her during sports day, because the class assistants thought that help from anyone would single her out. Who’s on first?
No, no one should be put in that position, and I have my head in my hands with that 2nd example. Once again I can see how lucky we are to live where we do, where access is a steadily improving situation, and treated seriously.
Those days of being manhandled on to rollercoasters are long gone for me, but I loved it and felt included. Also I felt stared at.
I long for the day when access just is, and no special treatment or consideration is needed. To just bled in.
I haven’t read this story, but I’m now off to Google.
I linked the original story and also Meriah’s piece on it. <3
Lorna once again you show us all how far we have yet to go. A great post and a wakeup call. P.s. your Dad sounds a smasher.
While I agree with accessibility, there are something that will never be accessible nor safe to non-ambulatory people, such as natural wonders, ie: grand canyon, Mt. Everest, gorge trails. My son is non-ambulatory and I was thrilled when a friend of ours carried him on his back up and down a natural gorge trail, something my son would have never had the opportunity to do if not for this friend. If you read the whole Team Ryan page, you will see that Ryan and her family are all about inclusion and accessibility, from pageants, to sports and etc. The teacher who stepped up hardly knew Ryan, but wanted to give her the opportunity to see a river bed and fossils. He wasn’t looking for praise or notoriety, just a plan good guy and dedicated teacher.
I’m not complaining about the family or the story. Just how it was framed.
This is touching truth that we see. I love visiting places and few of them have accessible drive/trail ways that are good for wheelchairs and strollers. I feel happy for them that they get to use it and enjoy with rest of their families. But yes for places like hiking trails , I don’t see access for disabled people.
Another excellent post Lorna and you’ve really captured an issue that all disabled people seem to run into. Access to do things others do is one of my biggest pet peeves…I struggle with access to buildings that are supposedly “handicap friendly”. Since when is a 2 inch lip on the floor between rooms accessible? I could go on and on, but you experience it all so you know.
Thanks for writing such great articles for us. I appreciate your wisdom and your expertise!!
Thanks, Pamela. I appreciate you. I know that there’s a difference between accessible with assistance and complete level access, but the lines are interesting.
I haven’t heard of this story but am sad that more children don’t have the chance to experience what their able-bodied peers are able to… but I’m mostly angry that anyone would think your father’s behavior was inappropriate. It’s kind of cringeworthy that anyone would jump to a weird conclusion and make you feel isolated by what happened. Your dad saw a need and, as most fathers would do, he stepped in to make sure you had the same experience as your classmates. Shame on the Girl Scouts got excluding you. Their loss ❤️
Like Charlotte above, I hadn’t heard this story and I am angry that there isn’t more inclusiveness in the world, but I’m even angrier about your experience with the Girl Scouts. Your dad was doing what dads do as you said and you guys shouldn’t have been chastised like that. I want to go back in time and tell those moms to chill the F out. <3
I live on the shores of Lake Superior, in Wisconsin. A popular place to go is Wisconsin Point and over the years it became kind of run down and a pain in the ass to get to the water even for us who are fully ambulatory. The city, with funds from wherever, decided it was going to make it an all access area, so they spent millions cleaning the beach up, building a beautiful boardwalk so someone in a wheelchair/with a mobility aid could easily get from the parking area all the way to the beach and enjoy the water. People were UP IN ARMS about that kind of money spent on the project asking if it was even necessary. That was bad enough but then some vandal actually put an explosive device and damaged the boardwalk so it’s unusable to everyone and we have to wait until next year to fix it, assuming there is money to do so. And I cannot for the life of me understand why people get angry when we make things all inclusive? I just don’t understand any of it. But you’re right- people really are the worst sometimes and while I always hope things will get better, I realize a lot of these people are parents and they are raising kids to (presumably) be like them. :/
Lorna, just came over from Janice Wald’s autumn blog party. Your experience with the scouts was horrible. That Brownie leader clearly had issues of her own!
I fully agree with you, Lorna. Yes, it’s a touching story. Yes, the teacher deserves praise, which is not why he did it. Therein lies the problem – crip porn. Ableism for money. These “news” services salve the fears of able-bodied readers. I’m reminded of a story about a teen who was given an expensive, custom power chair. They wrote of all it would do and ignored the thousands of teens who do without. And for that they get paid.
Yes, George! I saw that one, too. If it’s the one I’m thinking, the chair the friend bought for his friend doesn’t even fit in the wheelchair-user’s house. Disabled people’s lives are more than just feel-good stories.